Resources · Making lowball offers that actually close
What to offer on a distressed property: the formula
Updated July 11, 2026 · by the LowBaller team
The offer on a distressed property is a formula, not a feeling: start from estimated market value, apply the discount the scenario supports, then cap the result so it still clears the seller's debt. If the capped number no longer works for your exit, pass. Here is each step with real numbers.
Step 1: establish value without romance
Use the estimated market value as-is, not the after-repair fantasy. Automated valuations are imperfect but consistent, and consistency is what a pricing system needs. On a property estimated at 640,000 dollars, that number is your anchor for everything downstream.
Step 2: apply the scenario discount
The situation sets the discount, and the model's typical bands are tighter than folklore suggests.
| Scenario | Typical start bid | Typical close |
|---|---|---|
| Auction scheduled | 50% under value | 40 to 45% under |
| Pre-foreclosure + stacked signals | 45 to 50% under | 40 to 45% under |
| Tax delinquent 2+ years | 40 to 45% under | 35 to 40% under |
| Vacant, long-held | 35 to 45% under | 30 to 38% under |
| Inherited, heirs remote | 35 to 40% under | 28 to 35% under |
| Absentee + high equity | 25 to 35% under | 15 to 28% under |
Step 3: cap at the equity
Compute the seller's payoff: open mortgage plus roughly 3 to 5 percent for closing and cure costs. Your offer must exceed it. Example: value 640,000, scenario says offer 275,000, owner owes 190,000. The offer clears the debt with about 75,000 to the seller, so it can close. Same scenario but a 450,000 mortgage kills the deal; no motivated seller can accept a check that does not exist.
Step 4: sanity-check your exit
For a flip: your all-in (price plus repairs plus carry plus sale costs) should sit at or under 75 percent of after-repair value. For a rental: the net yield has to beat your alternative use of the cash. If the equity cap pushed the price above what your exit supports, the discipline is walking, not stretching.
Frequently asked questions
What is the 70 percent rule?
A flipper's shorthand: pay no more than 70 percent of after-repair value minus repair costs. It is a useful ceiling check, but it ignores the seller's mortgage. The equity cap, offer must clear the payoff, is the constraint that decides whether any number can close.
How much under market do distressed properties sell for?
Hard distress like scheduled auctions and multi-year tax delinquency typically closes 35 to 45 percent under estimated value for cash. Softer situations like absentee fatigue close 15 to 30 percent under. Equity depth decides whether those numbers are achievable.
Should I offer on a distressed property with no equity?
Not a normal cash offer; there is nothing to discount. Low-equity distress is short-sale territory, which means negotiating with the lender, longer timelines and uncertain approval. Most investors are better served moving to the next high-equity lead.
Put this to work in your market.
Scan any US ZIP and see every motivated seller near you, ranked hardest-first.
Find motivated sellers