Resources · Making lowball offers that actually close
Seller countered your lowball offer? The counter math, scripts and when to walk
Updated · by the LowBaller team
If the seller countered your lowball offer, respond with a smaller move than theirs, tied to a reason or a term, not a split down the middle. Their counter tells you they are willing to deal; your job is to close the gap in shrinking steps and stop at the ceiling you set before you made the first offer. Below are the counter math, a concession ladder you can copy, the terms worth more to sellers than they cost you, word-for-word replies, and the arithmetic that tells you when to walk.
First, the good news. A counter is not a rejection. A seller who was insulted or uninterested would not have answered with a number.
What a counter to your lowball offer really means
A counter tells you three things. The seller is willing to sell. Your reasoning landed well enough to keep them talking. And their number is an opening position, not their floor.
Read the size of their move. Example: list price $300,000, your offer $165,000, a gap of $135,000. A counter at $290,000 means they moved $10,000 and are testing you. A counter at $230,000 means they moved $70,000, more than half the gap, and are serious.
Then ask what is driving their number. It may be the payoff, a figure a family member wants, or what a neighbor got. Each needs a different answer, and only the payoff is a hard floor. (If you are the seller reading this, see how to respond to a lowball offer.)
The meet-in-the-middle trap
Splitting the difference feels fair, which is why sellers suggest it. But the midpoint only rewards whoever opened furthest from the real value. If the seller lists high and you open low, the midpoint is just the average of two anchors.
Example: on a $300,000 house, your ceiling is $203,000 (by the 70 percent rule: 70 percent of a $340,000 after-repair value, minus $35,000 of repairs). You open at $165,000. The seller counters at $260,000. The midpoint is $212,500, which is $9,500 over your ceiling. Agree to it and you either lose money or back out later, which is worse for the seller than an honest no today.
In the same example, a concession ladder that moves $7,000, then $5,000, then $3,000 ends at $180,000, with each step traded for a term, if the seller accepts the final step.
Worked example: midpoint vs concession ladder
$9,500 over your ceiling
The concession ladder: how much to move each round
Plan your moves before the counter arrives, starting from a ceiling you worked out in advance (see how to calculate your maximum allowable offer). Each step should be smaller than the last, so the seller can see you nearing your limit, and each should buy something in return.
LowBaller's suggested offer gives you the anchors for the ladder before you start: a start bid and a likely close, capped so the price still clears the owner's estimated mortgage and closing costs. Check your own ceiling in the lowball offer calculator.
| Round | Your number | Your move | What you ask for in return |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening | $165,000 | Start bid | Cash, as-is, closing on their date |
| Round 1 | $172,000 | +$7,000 | A 5-day inspection instead of 10 |
| Round 2 | $177,000 | +$5,000 | No repair credits after inspection |
| Round 3 | $180,000 | +$3,000 | Access for your contractor before closing |
| Final | $180,000 | No further move | Signed acceptance this week |
Say the reason for each move
Name why you can move: if we can do a 5-day inspection, I can get to $172,000. A reason makes each step feel earned, and a shrinking step tells the seller the end is close.
Counter with terms, not just price
Some concessions cost you little and are worth a lot to a seller under pressure. Offer them before you offer more money.
| Term you can give | Cost to you | Value to the seller |
|---|---|---|
| Closing on the seller's date | Low | High: fits a move, a sale date or a probate step |
| Rent-back for 2 to 4 weeks after closing | Low to moderate | High: no double move |
| Buying with tenants in place | Moderate | High for tired landlords |
| Leaving behind anything they do not want | The cleanout cost | High for estates and vacant houses |
| Paying the seller's closing costs | Typically 1 to 3% of price | Moderate: more cash in hand |
| Moving cash at closing | A fixed amount you choose | High when they have little cash now |
| A larger earnest money deposit | Cash tied up, not spent | Moderate: shows you will close |
Scripts for responding to a counter offer
When the counter is far from your number: Thank you for coming back with a number. That tells me we can probably work something out. I can't get to $260,000 because of the roof and the work inside, but I can move to $172,000 if we can do a 5-day inspection. What matters most to you besides price?
When they ask to meet in the middle: I understand why splitting it sounds fair. The problem is that the middle is above what the house supports for me after repairs. Here is what I can do: $177,000, closing on the date you pick.
When you are at your ceiling: I've gone as far as I can at $180,000. I'd rather tell you that honestly than agree to something I can't close on. If it works, we can sign this week. If not, I understand, and I'll check in with you in a few weeks.
When the counter reveals their payoff: Thank you for telling me what you owe. Let me see if I can make the numbers work above that. If I can't, I'll tell you straight away so you can look at other options.
When they counter on terms, not price: That date works for me. Can we keep the price at $172,000 if I match your closing date?
When to walk away from a counter
Walk away when the math says no deal exists, not when you feel annoyed. The test: if the seller's floor is above your ceiling, no number works for both of you. The floor is their mortgage payoff plus other liens, closing costs and the cash they need. Your ceiling is what your exit supports. If their floor is $215,000 and your ceiling is $203,000, stop negotiating price and say so kindly.
Walking away well keeps the door open. Leave your number in writing with a follow-up date, because a seller with a deadline may come back as it gets closer. Walk when:
- Their floor is above your ceiling.
- They will not move at all after two rounds, and no deadline is coming.
- They want you to skip the title search or close without a title company or attorney.
- Someone else on the title is not on board and will not sign.
- You feel pressure to stretch past your ceiling.
How to respond to a counter offer, step by step
- 1
Thank them and slow down
Acknowledge the counter the same day, but do not answer the number on the spot.
- 2
Find out what drives their number
Ask what the counter is based on: the payoff, a price someone wants, or a neighbor's sale.
- 3
Recheck your ceiling and their floor
Update both with anything new, such as a payoff figure or a repair quote.
- 4
Offer a term before money
Try a closing date, a rent-back or a cleanout first.
- 5
Make a shrinking move with a reason
If you move on price, move less than last time and say why.
- 6
Put every counter in writing
Send each new number as a written counter or amendment your attorney or agent has approved, so nobody misremembers it.
- 7
Stop at your ceiling
Say it clearly, leave the offer open and set a follow-up date, for example in the notes of LowBaller's My deals. More tactics in negotiating with motivated sellers.
Frequently asked questions
What do I do if the seller counters my lowball offer?
Thank them, find out what drives their number, then respond with a smaller move than theirs, tied to a reason or a term. Avoid splitting the difference, because the midpoint can land above your ceiling. Plan your concession steps in advance and stop at the ceiling you set before the first offer.
Should I meet the seller in the middle?
Only if the midpoint is at or below your ceiling and you have traded something for it. The middle rewards whoever opened furthest away, so it can land above what the deal supports. A shrinking concession ladder, where each step is smaller and tied to a term, keeps you in control of where the deal ends.
How much should I come up after a counter offer?
Less than the seller came down, and less each round. One workable pattern is a first move of a few percent of price, then smaller steps, each tied to a term like a shorter inspection or the seller's closing date. In a worked example on a $300,000 house, steps of $7,000, $5,000 and $3,000 end at $180,000.
When should I walk away from a counter offer?
Walk away when the seller's floor, their payoff plus liens and closing costs, is above your ceiling, because then no price works for both of you. Also walk when they will not move after two rounds and no deadline is ahead. Leave your offer in writing with a follow-up date, since deadlines change minds.
Is a counter offer a good sign?
Yes. A counter means the seller is willing to sell and willing to negotiate with you, and their number is an opening position, not their floor. The size of the move matters: a seller who comes down more than half the gap in one step is signaling they want to reach a deal.
Put this to work in your market.
Scan any US ZIP and see every motivated seller near you, ranked hardest-first.
Find motivated sellersKeep reading
- Negotiating with motivated sellers: scripts that work
- Lowball offer scripts: phone, voicemail, email and reply text
- Lowball offer mistakes: 11 that kill deals, and the fix for each
- How to respond to a lowball offer on your house (and when to accept it)
- The 70% rule in real estate: the formula, worked examples, and when it fails